Frequently Asked Questions

back to top

How much energy will Kingdom Community Wind produce?

The wind farm being considered in Lowell, Vermont holds the potential to meet the annual electrical needs of approximately 24,000 average households, that’s about 50,000 Vermonters! By harnessing the power of the wind locally, KCW will keep more of our electric dollars local and will contribute to stabilizing electric prices for generations to come. Kingdom Community Wind will help reduce the need to import power and will reduce pollution in our wider community.

back to top

 Where will the electricity go?

Green Mountain Power (GMP) and Vermont Electric Co-op (VEC) are partnering in this local Vermont renewable generation project. Both are focused on adding clean, new renewable energy sources to their power portfolio and are very interested in securing a reliable, long-term electrical supply to help bring price stability to generations of their Vermont members/customers. KCW will be part of the trend towards Vermonters controlling more of their generation sources and meeting state and federal renewable energy goals!

back to top

How does wind, as a generation source, integrate into our electric grid?

Vermont is part of the New England electric power grid known as ISO New England (ISO-NE, more information at www.iso-ne.com), which is comprised of many types of generators: nuclear, coal, hydro, wind, biomass - and especially natural gas (+/- 40%). The grid is designed to handle varying electric loads and various types of generation facilities supplying the electricity. Operation forecasting monitors weather conditions, total expected generation, and projected actions required to maintain system reliability. Grid operators are aware of the changing generating sources whether it is a large nuclear plant or a smaller wind facility. They are prepared to interchange various “quick-start” generation sources, such as natural gas and hydro plants when needed. Wind is grouped with other “on-demand” sources of electricity, meaning that it will be used when it is available.

back to top

How much pollution will be displaced or otherwise prevented?

Due to the complex nature of the regional electric grid and the rules under which it operates, it is nearly impossible to forecast the exact amount of pollution KCW will prevent, as the source of generation displaced by KCW will vary from time to time. On average the American Wind Energy Association has estimated that each megawatt of wind capacity built displaces 1,800 tons of C02 per year given the current mix of generation fuels. On average a 63 megawatt KCW facility would displace over 75,000 tons of C02 per year. On a larger scale, the US Department of Energy has estimated that meeting 20% of the country’s electrical needs with wind could “reduce the electrical sector’s natural gas requirements by about 50% and its coal requirements by about 18%” - which translates into avoiding up to 825 million tons of CO2 emissions annually, along with a multitude of other pollutants.

back to top

How often do turbines generate electricity?

The Vestas wind turbines selected for use at Kingdom Community Wind are designed to generate electricity in a range of wind speeds from 7 mph to 56 mph. Preliminary wind resource data gathered at the KCW site indicate turbines will generate electricity over 80% of the time. This is a different metric than a wind farm’s capacity factor, which compares the actual energy production over the course of a year with the amount that would have been produced had the wind farm run at maximum output over the course of the year.

back to top

What is “capacity factor” and how productive do you expect the wind turbines to be?

Capacity factor is a measure of the productivity of power generation facilities. Capacity factor compares the actual production over the course of a year with the amount that would have been produced had the facility run at maximum output over the course of the year. This is expressed as a percentage. With the Vestas V112 3.0MW wind turbine selected, KCW expects a capacity factor of about 33%. For purposes of comparison, the 2003 Vermont Renewable Power Supply Acquisition Authority Report indicates the TransCanada Deerfield and Connecticut River dams have a 27% capacity factor. While some facilities operate at capacity factors upwards of 85% in the New England electrical grid, there are others with less than 1% capacity factors. With wind generation, the size of the rotor and the size of the electric generator are important in these calculations. A large rotor with a small generator would see the wind turbine operating whenever the wind blew, and would record a high capacity factor, however it would produce little electricity because of the small generator size. Capacity factor is not a measure of the efficiency of a wind turbine.

back to top

Will the wind turbines have lights on them?

Yes. The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) will determine the number of lights needed for Kingdom Community Wind. Generally we would expect lights to be required at each end of the turbine array, with a light approximately every 1/2 mile in between – so a wind farm along three miles of ridgeline could be expected to require approximately seven lights. The Federally regulated safety lighting used is typically mounted on the top of the nacelle (housing enclosing the generator) of those wind turbines requiring a light. It is possible that the FAA will allow the use of lights that are less visible from lower elevations (for example, that are surrounded by shields that block their visibility from certain angles). If the FAA approves such technology, it will be pursued as required by its certificate of public good.

What is shadow flicker?

The term “shadow flicker” is used to describe a moving shadow that can occur in certain conditions when rotating turbine blades come between the viewer and the sun. This effect is usually confined to areas immediately proximate to the turbines, and even there occurs only a fraction of the time. As part of the permitting process, a shadow flicker analysis has been conducted. State regulators determined that there will be no undue impacts as a result of shadow flicker for this project.

back to top

What sound do wind turbines make and will I hear it?

There are two kinds of sound associated with the operation of wind turbine generation: 1) the sound of the wind passing by the blades and 2) in older, less insulated equipment, sound from the generator. Thanks to advances in wind turbine technology, at distances of 350 meters, or 1,140 feet, away, the US Department of Energy says modern turbines "registered just about a quiet bedroom for sound level at 35 to 45 decibels", which compares to about 40 decibels for a rural night-time background. There are very few homes or camps less than 3,000 feet away from the proposed turbine locations.

back to top

What environmental impacts will result from the installation of Kingdom Community Wind?

The project’s developers, state and federal environmental experts and regulators have closely studied the potential impacts of the project. All necessary environmental permits must be received and complied with, as well as additional conditions placed on KCW as a result of its certificate of public good (CPG) issued by the Vermont Public Service Board (PSB). With those requirements, including mitigation plans for known impacts, the regulators have determined that KCW poses no undue adverse impacts to the environment. 

back to top

Will Kingdom Community Wind stop recreational use surrounding the wind turbines?

Kingdom Community Wind is being proposed on private land. Access to the area is restricted at the landowner’s discretion. Typically at wind power projects, recreational use such as hunting can continue if allowed by the landowner.

back to top

Will the wind turbines shed ice during winter storms?

Ice throw from wind turbines blades is relatively uncommon. When ice or glazing does form on turbine components, it normally drops to the ground in the vicinity of the base of the wind turbine tower. The risk of damage from falling ice is minimized by the employment of technology to control the turbine’s operation. The wind turbines at this site are remote from residences and buildings, making the likelihood of ice-related damage to personal property negligible.

back to top

Will there be a new high-voltage power line on the site?

The electricity generated by the wind turbines will be collected underground along the ridgeline, transmitted on a single-poled overhead collection line down the mountain and north along Rt 100 to an existing substation at the intersection of Rt. 100 and Rt. 58 in Lowell village, where it will interconnect with the existing regional power grid. We anticipate the use of a 34 Kv line to reach the substation, which for purposes of comparison is the size of the VEC line presently running along Rt. 100 between Lowell and Jay.

back to top

Will the wind turbines be fenced or secured from public access?

Wind turbines are not typically fenced and since the property on which the turbines are located is private, any access road will be gated. Due to normal safety precautions, access into the area around the wind turbines themselves, and where operational controls are located, is secure to prevent unauthorized access and provide public safety.

back to top

Will there be increased traffic in the area associated with Kingdom Community Wind?

Kingdom Community Wind will have a negligible impact on traffic during its operating life. During the construction period, there will be increased traffic and localized traffic delays during delivery of the turbines and construction materials. Plans for construction truck routes and frequency of deliveries have not been developed at this time. The wind farm will utilize typical service pick-up trucks for routine maintenance access. Areas around wind farms elsewhere have reported a slight increase in tourism-related traffic.

back to top

How will the wind farm be accessed?

KCW has secured access rights directly off of Rt. 100 in Lowell to the 1800 acre parcel where the wind farm will be located. This property has been heavily logged for generations, providing an established network of roads that will be utilized to the maximum extent possible.

back to top

What is the expected life of Kingdom Community Wind?

The current generation of wind turbines has a useful life expectancy of 25 years. If the project is repowered after that time, our utility partners have the exclusive option to continue generation, ensuring that KCW will continue to benefit generations of Vermonters.

back to top

Is there a plan for taking down the wind turbines once the life of Kingdom Community Wind is over?

As part of the development and permitting processes, a decommissioning plan will be prepared, which will include the removal of above-ground equipment and site restoration in the event that power generation no longer occurs.

back to top

What is known about the impact of wind turbines on bats and birds?

Bat collision mortality is known to occur at operating wind farms. The Bat Wind Energy Cooperative (www.batandwind.org) , or BWEC, made up of representatives from Bat Conservation International, the US Fish and Wildlife Service, the US Department of Energy, and wind energy companies is investigating the cause of bat collisions. Research focuses on areas to address concerns regarding bats and wind energy: 1) pre-construction monitoring assesses bat activity levels; 2) post-construction studies estimate fatalities, compare fatality estimates among facilities, and determine patterns of fatality in relation to weather and habitat variables. Likewise, according to the US Department of Energy, wind energy’s impacts on birds are “quite small”. Out of every 10,000 birds killed by all human activity, less than 1 death is associated with wind turbines. By comparison, household cats are responsible for 1,000 deaths. There will be continued monitoring for bats and birds at KCW after the turbines are operation. 

back to top

How does a wind turbine make electricity?

Typical wind turbines consist of three rotor blades (rotor assembly), which rotate around a horizontal hub. The hub is connected to a shaft, gearbox and generator, which are located inside the nacelle. The nacelle is the large part at the top of the tower where the electrical components are located. Most wind turbines have three blades which face into the wind so that when the wind blows, it forces the blades to rotate, spinning the shaft and in turn the generator. A generator is a machine that produces electrical energy from mechanical energy, as opposed to an electric motor which does the opposite.

back to top

How big will the wind turbines be?

 The Vestas V112 3.0MW turbine stands 459’ from the ground to the tip of the blade at its highest point.

back to top

What are the benefits of Kingdom Community Wind?

 In addition to generating carbon and emission free electricity and helping to stabilize electric prices for generations of Vermonters, Kingdom Community Wind will pay hundreds of thousands of dollars annually towards Vermont’s education fund and Lowell’s municipal budget. Substantially reduced property taxes will be enjoyed by Lowell taxpayers (assuming town spending stays consistent with previous years), as Kingdom Community Wind would place minimal, if any, additional demand on town services such as schools and emergency services.

 Kingdom Community Wind will generate and deliver clean energy to the local power grid, reducing the need for energy generation from other sources. This means cleaner air and a healthier environment.

back to top

Why do we need to build wind turbines on ridgelines? Why not put them at lower elevations closer to population centers?

 Wind turbines need to be located where the wind is, as each incremental increase in wind speed results in an exponential increase in a turbine’s electrical output. The simple fact is that in Vermont the wind speeds are higher, and more consistent, at the higher elevations.

back to top

Does wind work?

Absolutely. Wind provides clean, renewable energy. There is some confusion about a wind farm’s “capacity factor” and the percent of the time the wind farm is generating electricity. Wind plants actually generate power about 80 percent of the time. They generate at their full capacity during relatively strong winds, but they still generate electricity during lighter winds, much as the generation of a river-run hydro plant varies with variations in water levels. The expected capacity factor at KCW is approximately 33%, which means that if we build a 63 megawatt wind farm, it will generate approximately 180,000 megawatthours of electricity every year, or enough for 24,000 homes.

 back to top

Will the value of my property be affected?
 
We know this is a very important question to people who live in Lowell and neighboring communities. While studies so far have had mixed results, the largest and most comprehensive peer reviewed scientific study ever conducted was released in 2009 and is available on-line at http://eetd.lbl.gov/ea/ems/reports/lbnl-2829e.pdf. Researchers analyzed over 7,000 home sales surrounding more than 1,000 modern turbines. They found “no statistical evidence that homes with a view of wind turbines have different values or appreciation rates than homes without such views.”
 
However, it’s reasonable to be concerned that there could be isolated cases where some properties values are affected, and, in fact, the study indicates that “though one cannot rule out isolated cases where property values are negatively impacted, any such impacts within our sample are neither widespread nor statistically identifiable.” In this regard, the tax payment to Lowell (which will likely cover the entire municipal budget) should be an attractive selling point for residents looking to buy property.
 
 
Does the sound produced by wind turbines cause health effects?
 
Health effects from wind turbine noise have been studied, and an objective scientific advisory panel has concluded that “There is no evidence that the audible or sub-audible sounds emitted by wind turbines have any direct adverse physiological effects.”  
 
More than 50,000 turbines currently are in operation in Europe and more than 30,000 in North America, and most people consider them good neighbors. It is true that some individuals have complained that living near turbines causes adverse health effects due noise. We are unaware of any objective scientific study to support these claims.
 
Wind turbines produce noise when they operate. There is nothing unique about the type of noise made by a wind turbine. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, at a distance of 1,140 feet, modern wind turbines can be expected to be about as noisy as a quiet bedroom – 35-45 decibels, which compares to about 40 decibels for a typical rural night-time background.
 
Wind turbines should be located a respectful distance from residences. In Lowell, the nearest distance to a year-round residence will be approximately 3000 feet, or almost three times farther away than described above. 
 
Finally, a reliable way to understand what a turbine sounds like is to visit an operating wind farm or to speak with someone who has visited one. As you may know, Green Mountain Power offered local residents the opportunity to visit the wind farm in Lempster, NH in early December 2009, and February 2010. The turbines were generating power when we were there. Most people reported that they couldn’t hear anything until they came within approximately 1,000 feet of the turbines.
                                                                                                                                           
 
 
Is wind generation subsidized?
 
Yes. Wind power enjoys federal tax incentives. These incentives will reduce the cost of the project, and “flow through” to VEC and GMP customers. .
 
It is also important to bear in mind that many forms of electric generation enjoy federal and sometimes state tax or other financial incentives. Wind is not unique in this regard.
 
 
Does it matter that the wind doesn’t always blow?
 
No. Wind generation is very much like the hydro-electric generation that has generated electricity on Vermont’s rivers for almost a century. Like hydro, wind is an intermittent resource, which means that it does not generate 100 percent of the time.
 
Most electric generating plants do not run 100% of the time. Some are designed to run most of the time, like nuclear plants, while others are designed to run only when customer demand is at its highest, like gas turbines. Renewable resources, in general, run when the “fuel” is available, whether it is the sun, water or wind.
 
The electric grid adjusts every hour, as customer demand increases and decreases. The grid is designed to accommodate the different operating characteristics of all types of generation. Intermittent resources are easily incorporated into the total operation of the grid. The benefit of wind generation is that when the wind is blowing, generation at other plants in New England, most often fossil fuel plants, can be reduced.
  
 
What about the “Voices of Tug-Hill” video many opponents have been passing out?
 
While we have no doubt that the handful of people featured in the “Voices of Tug-Hill” video are being sincere, they do not represent the majority of people living amongst and near the Maple Ridge Wind Farm (a 195 turbine, 321 MW wind farm located on the Tug Hill plateau in Lewis County, NY). The Tug Hill Commission and Lewis County have conducted three separate scientific surveys, which together surveyed over 1,700 residents and landowners. More than 70% think the wind farm has had a positive effect on their area and they want more turbines.
 
At Tug Hill, the 2008 Lewis County survey specifically asked residents about noise. 3.6% of respondents lived within 2500 feet of a turbine, but only 1.8% could hear turbines from their home.
 
 
How does wind keep pollutants out of the air?
 
Every hour that a wind plant is generating electricity, a plant – for the most part fossil fuel fired -- somewhere else in New England does not need to operate. Demand for electricity is constantly changing, not only between the seasons, but hour to hour, even minute to minute, throughout each and every day. The New England “grid,” which is comprised of the transmission system and the generators supplying the power, is designed to accommodate and adapt to this constantly changing demand. Some baseload plants (such as Vermont Yankee) operate 24 hours a day, but other “peaking” plants are designed to be turned on and off relatively quickly depending on the need for the power. This means that if a wind plant is generating, other plants are not needed and can be turned off. Because most of New England’s peaking generation plants are powered by natural gas, wind can play a vital role in reducing the use of fossil fuels by ramping down those plants.
 
 
Will the power stay in Vermont?
 
YES! It’s power produced by Vermonters for Vermonters. All the power will be used by Green Mountain Power and Vermont Electric Cooperative customers. Not a single kilowatthour will be sold out of state. The project is being proposed to provide customers of both utilities with stably-priced, renewable energy.
 
 
Will the Renewable Energy Credits (RECs) be sold?
 
The purpose of the REC market is to provide incentives to develop renewable generation, like wind power. In all New England states, except Vermont, utilities need RECs to meet state-mandated renewable energy requirements, and thus increase the amount of renewable energy they can claim. These out-of-state utilities are looking for RECs to purchase. Because of this, and because the Vermont legislature and governor encourage our utilities to sell their RECs in order to lower the cost of electricity for their ratepayers, it is likely that GMP and VEC will sell the RECs associated with KCW. When considering the REC issue it is also important to consider that GMP and VEC will control the RECs, meaning they can choose to sell them to benefit their respective ratepayers, or if the regulatory environment evolves so Vermont utilities are required to have RECs associated with a percentage of the electricity they sell, they can retain any RECs required (as opposed to having to buy them at market prices).
 
 
How can we be sure you will decommission the turbines and above-ground infrastructure?
 
Green Mountain Power will be responsible for decommissioning. We have agreed to pay the town taxes until the plant is decommissioned – meaning we will have to pay until the turbines are taken down and removed from the site. This means we will be highly motivated to remove the equipment when it is no longer operating. In addition, decommissioning is required as part of our permit. 
 
 
Will you be building wind turbines north of Bayley-Hazen Road?
 
No. We are only considering using the section of ridge between the Eden-Lowell town line to the south, and the northern edge of the Moose Mountain Forestry (i.e. Wileman) property to the north.
 
 
Will you be using property owned by members of the town selectboard?
 
No. While both Alden Warner and Richard Pion do own property along the ridge, these parcels are north of the area being considered for the wind farm. Members of the selectboard will only enjoy the same benefits as all Lowell taxpayers and VEC members.
 
 
Will you be using Farm Road for the project?
 
No. Access to the project will be from Route 100, more specifically via a yet to be built project access road across the field owned by Moose Mountain Forestry (about 1/2 mile north of Stewart Road). The transmission line will also run along this route.
 
 
How will this benefit Vermonters if Green Mountain Power is owned by a Canadian company?
 
Vermonters will benefit from all the stably priced, renewable energy generated by Kingdom Community Wind. As a utility-owned project, we can provide electricity to GMP and VEC customers more cost effectively than if the project were owned by an outside developer. It is like the difference between renting and owning – GMP’s and VEC’s customers will reap the long-term value (with VEC’s customers receiving all the benefits of utility ownership without the risks.)
 
GMP is incorporated in Vermont and has been doing business exclusively in Vermont for more than 100 years – we supply power to Vermonters, are operated and managed by Vermonters, and we are regulated by the Vermont Public Service Board for the benefit of our Vermont ratepayers. Quite simply, GMP is proud to be a Vermont company!
 
 
What is the significance of GMP currently being owned by Gaz Metro, a Canadian gas company? 
 
Prior to being purchased by Gaz Metro, GMP was traded on the New York Stock Exchange, and therefore had thousands of owners located all over the world, mostly outside of Vermont. Now GMP has one investor that is willing and able to spend millions of dollars developing renewable energy for the benefit of GMP’s and VEC’s customers. GMP will earn a regulated return on its investment, similar to the way interest would be paid if the money to build the project were borrowed from a bank. Gaz Metro will receive dividends based on GMP’s earnings, the same way that shareholders receive dividends on stocks that they own.
 
 
Will Gaz Metro benefit from tax credits?
 
No. Any tax credits will be applied to reduce the cost of power from the project to GMP and VEC customers. Unlike a private developer who can increase earnings through the tax credits, a regulated utility is required to pass along to customers any benefits that reduce the cost of the project.
 
 
What was the Lowell town meeting vote about?
 
The Lowell Select board decided to hold a vote at Town Meeting by Australian ballot to give citizens of the town an opportunity to determine whether the town wanted the utilities to move forward with filing for the permit to build a wind plant on Lowell Mountain. Green Mountain Power was clear from the very beginning that iIf the people of Lowell did not want the project, we would not build it. The vote was held on March 2, 2010, with 75% of the votes cast in support of the project. Of 581 registered votes, 456 cast votes, 342 in favor and 114 opposed.
  
  

 

Kingdom Community Wind
163 Acorn Lane, Colchester, VT 05446
Phone: 1-888-835-4672 | Email: info@kingdomcommunitywind.com

VT Nonprofit Web Design